We Buy Coins

How do I sell Rare Coins?

You’ve come to the right place, we are a local coin buyer!  Our family-operated coin shop is located in Lake in the Hills, IL (in between Randall Rd. and Route 47).

If you are looking to sell coins for cash, we buy a wide variety of coins. No coin collection is too big or small. We buy coins made of a variety of metals, not just gold coins and silver coins.

U.S. Rare Coins

Foreign Coins

U.S. Gold Coins

Foreign Gold Coins

Retail Location

9465 Ackman Rd.
Lake in the Hills, IL 60156

How much Are My Coins worth?

Coin values vary greatly by many factors. We value your coin collection based on the following:

  • Rarity
  • Denomination
  • Year minted
  • Mint Mark
  • Condition
  • Precious Metals market conditions
  • Desirability

Can I send you Pictures of My Coins?

Yes! We can’t guarantee we will have enough information to give you an accurate quote, but if you would like us to take a look, please send us an email with pictures to give us an idea of what you have.  Send Your Coin Pictures here.

How does The Process of selling Coins work?

Schedule a no-hassle appraisal with Hertel’s Coins, or stop in during our regular business hours. Our coin appraisal process is simple, upfront, and pressure-free.

  1. Make an appointment or stop in during business hours for a coin appraisal.

  2. An appointment is not required for a quick 15-minute estimate.

  3. We will review all items and provide you with an offer to buy your coin collection.

  4. You can sell your coins on the spot! The choice is yours!
20 Years Experience

Why Us?

As an authorized coin dealer for PCGS, NGC, PMG & CAC we are a submission center for coin grading coins & notes.

Hertel’s Coin Shop buys coins and sells coins. Sell your coins with confidence to an experienced and reputable coin dealer. We will appraise old coins from one coin to an extensive coin collection. Sell coins with confidence to vetted experts who are authorized coin dealers by these major coin grading companies. Hertel’s Coins appraises coins, buys coins & sells coins. Let us appraise your estate jewelry and coin collections.

What our customers are saying...

Cristin Evans
Cristin Evans
Read More
Highly recommend! Shaun and Brandy came out to our house to give us an appraisal. We did a great deal of research ahead of time and contacted several shops. I immediately felt comfortable during the initial phone conversation and within minutes of being in our home felt like we were talking to old friends. Shaun was incredibly thorough and based on our research the price he offered was very fair! Thankful we found Hertels!
Tonya Jenkins
Tonya Jenkins
Read More
Best coin dealer in the area! Appraisal of my inherited coin collection was simple and fast. They explained to me not only coin values but also shared some history about a few of the coins. I would do business again with them and highly recommend this coin shop!
Chris Prescott
Chris Prescott
Read More
I definitely recommend this place and will be a repeat customer. Saturday 3/14 was my first time buying silver and I had several questions for Shaun and his wife. They both took the time to answer my questions and helped make recommendations based on the long term strategy I am looking to achieve.
Jon Stosky
Jon Stosky
Read More
Shaun and Brandy, thanks for taking the time to go over my father's coin collection with me. Shaun, I really appreciate you sharing your historical knowledge regarding the type of U.S. coins I had and of course the free appraisal. Brandy, my wife enjoyed speaking with you as well, we felt welcomed as if we knew you both for years! We know we received a good price for our coin collection! Should we ever have a need in the future, we'll definitely work with you!
Dani Divine
Dani Divine
Read More
I went in with some coins & cards. Very clean place and he was very knowledgeable & offered me, what I believe to have been a fair price. Thank you for being reliable & kind.
Previous
Next

The Hertel's Coins Difference

Hertel’s Coins knows that you can work with many places that buy coins. We assure you that you will walk away with knowledge when working with us and be treated with courtesy and respect every time. As a coin specialist, we strive to ensure each customer is a repeat customer at our coin shop!

When you sell your coins, gold, or jewelry to Hertel’s Coins, you can be confident the transaction will be fair and honest. We hope to become your go-to, best place to sell precious metals and coins!

We also offer gold and silver exchange if you prefer to trade.

Retail Location

9465 Ackman Rd.
Lake in the Hills, IL 60156

Ask us about your gold!

Hertel’s Coins buys gold, gold bullion, gold jewelry, silver bullion, silver jewelry, silver coins, diamonds, U.S. Coins and Foreign Coins, U.S. paper money and foreign paper money,  sterling silver flatware and other sterling items, silver plate items, military memorabilia, sports cards including baseball cards and collectible comics.